From the Final Report:
STARGATE (Static Repository Gateway and Toolkit)
was funded by the Joint Information Systems Committee (JISC) and
is intended to demonstrate the ease of use of the Open Archives
Initiative Protocol for Metadata Harvesting (OAI-PMH) Static Repository
technology, and the potential benefits offered to publishers in
making their metadata available in this way This technology offers
a simpler method of participating in many information discovery
services than creating fully-fledged OAI-compliant repositories.
It does this by allowing the infrastructure and technical support
required to participate in OAI-based services to be shifted from
the data provider (the journal) to a third party and allows a single
third party gateway provider to provide intermediation for many
data providers (journals).
Specifically, STARGATE has created a series of Static Repositories
of publisher metadata provided by a selection of Library and Information
Science journals. It has demonstrated the interoperability of these
repositories by exposing their metadata via a Static Repository
Gateway for harvesting and cross-searching by external service
providers. The project has conducted a critical evaluation of the
Static Repository approach in conjunction with the participating
publishers and service providers.
The technology works. The project has
demonstrated that Static Repositories are easy to create and
that the differences between
fully-fledged and static OAI Repositories have no impact on the
participation of small journal publishers in OAI-based services.
The problems for a service that arise out of the use of Static
Repositories are parallel to those created by any other repository
dealing with journal articles. Problems arise from the diversity
of metadata element sets provided by a given journal and the lack
of specific metadata elements for the articles’ volume and
issue details. Another issue for the use of publishers’ metadata
arise as the collection policies of some existing services only
allow Open Access materials to be included in them.
The project recommends that the use
of Static Repositories continues to be explored – in particular
as a flexible way to expose existing sets of structured information
to OAI services and to
create the opportunity to enhance the metadata as part of the process.
The project further recommends that the publishing community consider
the creation or adoption of an application profile for journal
articles to support information discovery that can search by volume
and issue. Significant further use of the Static Repository technology
by small journal publishers will require the future creation and
maintenance of a community-specific Static Repository Gateway.
Further use will also require advocacy within the publishing community
but might initially be most effectively kick-started through the
creation of OAI repositories based on metadata held by the commercial
services which publish or mediate access to electronic copies of
journals on behalf of small publishers.